KrampusKrampus is the clearest winner. Bad Tidings used to be easy to shut down, because an opponent holding Coal could gain CP at the right moment and wipe their own Coal before the collateral damage landed. Under the new rules they can't respond that way, so Bad Tidings hits for its full damage even when the opponent already holds some Coal. That makes it a regular choice instead of a lane Krampus only uses when the opponent sits at zero Coal. This hurts most against heroes who can gain CP on demand. Forgemaster scrapping Ore or Jean Grey cashing in Acuity used to be able to wipe a full stack of Coal after it landed, and anyone holding a Getting Paid! could do the same, but now there's no window to do it before the damage is counted. Forgemaster is barely touched by the new rules otherwise, so Krampus may be a sleeper pick into him now. I'm not sure though, and I'll have to get reps in on the matchup to get a feel for it. Buh, Bye! coming back barely hurts him, since his Gifts and a single Coal aren't worth much to remove, which makes the opponent's copy a weak card against him. His Reject Deck is also untouched by the no reshuffle rule, so he still cycles it as before. I have him moving up from the top of Situational to the low end of Reliable. Cursed PirateCursed Pirate is the other clear winner. Her steals and discards, like Walk the Plank, Abyssal Walk and Pillage, used to be easy to play around. Once she locked in Walk the Plank and made her choice, an opponent could still spend their CP or play the card in response, so there was nothing left to take. Under the new rules that window is gone. They can still act when she announces the ability, before she has even chosen between stealing and discarding, but she acts first and can switch to a different ability if they do, and once the ability locks in it takes what is really there. Pillage can't be answered at all. Buh, Bye! coming back is a real answer to her, though. Parlay stops an opponent's attack from dealing any damage for a turn, so removing it is huge when they need to deal damage that turn. Heroes with other non damage abilities to use may opt to remove a Keg instead, but it's far from a dead card against her. She's one of the most played heroes in the game, so these changes will show up in a lot of matches. She is already at the end of Meta, so I don't have her changing tiers, but I do have her climbing within it. RavenessRaveness takes a real hit. What Status Effects now takes her entire Feather stack, and she can no longer spend Feathers in response, so holding a big bank is a liability. I think that will heavily incentivize Raveness pilots to burn Feathers to min/max the Nevermore roll instead of holding them, at least until the opponent plays What Status Effects. Buh, Bye! gives opponents a way to break Hex right after they roll the sixes they want to keep, and she loses a couple of her old tricks, like bringing Nevermore home to heal out of reach of a lethal hit and opening with Broken Stillness on turn one when going second. Her core engine is intact, since she can still re-roll and shift the Nevermore die on their turn, so I have her sliding down within Reliable rather than falling off. She's still one of the better heroes, just a less forgiving one. Shadow ThiefShadow Thief gets worse, mostly because Buh, Bye! is back and the attacker now acts first, so Shadows gained on defense or from Enter the Shadows! can be stripped before the damage lands. A skilled opponent will save Buh, Bye! until Shadow Thief burns dice mods to manufacture Shadows against a big incoming hit, and hope he isn't still holding Enter the Shadows! to bring Shadows right back. His deck no longer reshuffles either, which closes off the long games where he draws through everything, though that rarely happens in a timed match anyway. His Pickpocket steals and Card Trick discards can no longer be dodged either, which helps a little. None of this ends him, because a skilled Shadow Thief still wins the late game. A big Buh, Bye! on his Shadows can leave him a turn too late, but that won't happen every game. Opponents want to end this matchup early, so they're drawing fewer cards and have less of a chance to find Buh, Bye! in the first place. Still, I have him dropping from Meta to the top of Reliable. He's objectively worse under the new rules, but in the hands of a great pilot he's still incredibly potent. DruidDruid now has to shift into Bear Form before the attacker locks in their ability if he wants the extra defense dice, because they only count when he is already in Bear Form as he rolls. Shifting after the roll still gives him the extra prevention, but not the extra dice. In practice that means shifting right after an attack is announced, and any action the defender takes at that point lets the attacker change what they declared. Say a Cursed Pirate rolls something that qualifies for either Walk the Plank, a big defendable attack, or X Marks the Spot, an undefendable one. She announces Walk the Plank, Druid shifts into Bear to defend it, and she switches to X Marks the Spot. The shift buys him nothing and he is stuck in Bear Form. The same thing happens if the attacker is holding a card or status effect that makes the hit undefendable, because they can play it after he shifts. Being stuck means losing the Regenerate he gains in Druid Form at the end of his turn and the extra damage and Wound from Cat Form, and he has to find another Shape Shift to get out. Waiting until after his defense roll is safer, but then he gets less out of Bear Form. I'm not sure how often this comes up, since the attacker needs the right options and spare resources, so plenty of games won't see it. But into heroes with a natural undefendable pivot, or any way to make an attack undefendable after the defender has committed, I think Druid has to be much more careful about when he commits. I don't have him changing tiers, but he's a little further from the top of Reliable than before. CyclopsCyclops has the biggest swing of anyone, though he sees little play and was already at the bottom of my tier list. His Support and Battle Plan used to be spendable in response to status removal, so a full bank was safe, and now a full bank is just a target. He's also one of the heroes most likely to run through his whole deck, so losing the reshuffle costs him in long games. His tier doesn't change, but he moves even further from the pack. TacticianTactician gets clearly worse. Tactical Advantage used to be a safe thing to bank, because an opponent trying to remove it could be answered by spending it for CP, a draw or Protect. Now What Status Effects just takes the whole stack, so a big bank is a target instead of a safety net. Buh, Bye! coming back adds another way to hit Targeted or a banked Protect, and Protect can no longer be bought in response to isolated undefendable damage. Token re-rolls still work and the deck rarely runs out, so the hit comes almost entirely from the bank. I have the Tactician sliding further down within Struggles. Vampire LordVampire Lord is hurt badly by the new removal rules. Blood Power is her biggest and hardest to rebuild stack, and she used to be able to cash it in for a draw of two cards the moment an opponent tried to remove it. Now What Status Effects wipes it with no response, and Buh, Bye! gives opponents a way to pick off a single Blood Power, often the fourth token of a planned heal, or one of the Bleeds she's applied. She was already in Struggles, and this pushes her further toward the bottom of that group. |